3 Analysis of the current status
3.2.1 Ventilation systems for extracting the electroplating baths
As described above, there are 4 baths in area 1 with the designations "dechroming, deep bath 1, rectangular bath and long bath". The baths are listed in Figure 13.
Each bath is equipped with a slotted extraction system to prevent explosive mixtures. A pre-separator is installed within the duct system for each bath. Furthermore, the exhaust air is fed to a central scrubber. A central fan is installed downstream of the scrubber; the fan data is listed in Table 5.
Designation |
Unit |
Unit Value |
Volume flow |
m3/h |
10 000 |
Differential pressure (total) |
Pa |
2320 |
Electrical power |
kW |
12,5 |
Calculated air change range 1 |
1/h |
2,1 |
Tab. 5: Data of the central fan and the air change of area 1
Fig. 13: Illustration of the bathrooms and the ventilation systems for area 1 [IB Potthoff]The supply air is fed into area 1 via air inlet openings in the building envelope.
The hall is heated (statically) and the supply air (dynamically) via air circulation heaters.
Figure 13 shows the existing exhaust air system with the associated bathrooms for area 1.
Area 2 contains the "deep baths 2 to 6" as well as the electroplating nickel plating system, which consists of "bath 6".
The chemical nickel plating system includes the baths "impact nickel bath and two matt nickel baths".
Here too, the air in each bath is extracted via slotted extraction systems located at the edge of the bath.
A pre-separator is installed within the duct system for baths 2, 3 and 4.
Designation |
Unit |
Value |
Volume flow |
m3/h |
6000 |
Differential pressure (total) |
Pa |
2880 |
Electrical power |
kW |
7,5 |
Calculated air change range 2 |
1/h |
3,2 |
Tab. 6: Data of the central fans of the same type and the air change of area 2
Furthermore, the extract air is additionally cleaned with a central scrubber. A central fan is installed downstream of the scrubber.
The exhaust air from bathrooms 5 and 6 is each cleaned with a separate scrubber. A fan is installed downstream of each scrubber.
The data of the three central fans of the same type and the air exchange rate of area 2 are shown in Table 6.
As in zone 1, the supply air is fed to zone 2 via air inlet openings in the building envelope.
The hall (static) and the supply air (dynamic) are also heated here via recirculation heaters.
Fig. 14: Illustration of the bathrooms and ventilation systems for area 2 [IB Potthoff]Figure 14 shows the existing exhaust air systems with the associated bathrooms for area 2.
There is no supply air system corresponding to the exhaust air systems. As a result, considerable draughts occur, particularly in the cold season.
A large amount of energy from the production area is dissipated unused via the exhaust air systems, as heat recovery systems are not installed.
Determining the air volume flows of the relevant bathrooms
As can be seen from Figures 13 and 14, the relevant volume flows, in this case those of the galvanic baths, are not known. In order to be able to assess whether the specified volume flows of the fans are sufficiently dimensioned, the volume flows of the baths are determined below.
The minimum exhaust air volume flow Vmin is calculated on the basis of DIN EN 17059 [1]. Accordingly, the volume flow of the baths must be differentiated according to the protection criteria "inhalative and explosive hazards". The higher volume flow rate must then be taken into account.
According to the currently valid approval notice, the minimum volume flow for the "explosive hazard" is decisive and must be determined.
The evaluation of the minimum exhaust air volume flow for the baths is based on the following equation <1>. The substance considered was hydrogen H2, which is produced at the cathode during the galvanic process. The required minimum air volume flow was then determined using the lower explosion limit for hydrogen.
VH2 = c - l - t - ή - ρ/KoH2 Eq. <1>
Where are:
VH2 = volume flow [m3/h]
c = electrochemical deposition equivalent [g/Ah]
I = current [A]
t = time [h]
ή = Efficiency of the hard chrome plating [%]
ρ = Density [kg/m3]
KoH2 = Concentration H2 [vol. %] (permissible)
The results of the volume flow calculation are contained in Table 7.
Accordingly, the minimum volume flows listed in Table 7 must be produced at the respective baths to avoid explosive mixtures.
Designation |
Unit |
Value |
Volume flow Bath 1 |
m3/h |
3000 |
Volume flow bath 2 |
m3/h |
3000 |
Volume flow bath 3 |
m3/h |
3000 |
Bath volume flow 4 |
m3/h |
6000 |
Bath volume flow 5 |
m3/h |
3000 |
Bath volume flow 6 |
m3/h |
4000 |
Table 7: Required extraction volume flows of the baths
Fig. 15: Power consumption of the exhaust air fans in the bathrooms [IB Potthoff]As described above, the volume flows operated by the fans are not known. In order to be able to make an initial rough estimate of the volume flows of the fans in the actual state, the measured active power consumption of the fans over the period 1.2.2017 to 10.2.2017 is evaluated below. The evaluation is shown in Figure 15.
Figure 15 shows the production-dependent operating mode of the fans.
The fan for area 1 is operated constantly at 100 percent throughout the week and is switched off at the end of production over the weekend.
The fan for baths 2, 3 and 4 is operated in two stages, at 100 percent during the day and 50 percent at night.
The fan in bath 5 is operated constantly throughout the week during the day, although it is switched off for a few hours at night.
The fan in bath 6 and in the chemical nickel plating baths is operated constantly over the period. It is not switched off at weekends, for example.
All other fans are switched off at the weekend after the end of production.
Table 8 shows the measured electrical data of the exhaust air fans.
Designation |
Unit |
Value |
Electr. power fan range 1 |
kW |
10,7 |
Electr. power fan Electr. power fan bath 2, 3, 4 |
kW |
7,1 |
Bathroom fan electric power 5 |
kW |
6,2 |
Electr. power fan Electr. power fan bath 6 Nickel plating |
kW |
2,3 |
Power consumption fan range 1 |
kWh/a |
52 710 |
Power consumption fan Power consumption fan bathroom 2, 3, 4 |
kWh/a |
37 992 |
Bathroom fan power consumption 5 |
kWh/a |
23 939 |
Electricity consumption fan Electricity consumption fan bath 6 nickel plating |
kWh/a |
18 298 |
Total power consumption fans |
kWh/a |
132 940 |
Tab. 8: Electrical data of the exhaust air fans
Based on the electrical power listed in Table 7, the operating volume flow is evaluated using the following equation <2>.
V$_2$ = V$_1$ $\cdot$ $\frac{P_2
^3}{P_1^3}$ Eq. <2>
Where are:
V1 = volume flow rate operating point 1 (nameplate) [m3/h]
V2 = Volume flow rate operating point 2 [m3/h]
P1 = Electrical power operating point 1 (nameplate) [kW]
P2 = Electrical power operating point 2 (according to Table 7) [kW]
This procedure is only permissible if no structural changes have been made to the exhaust air systems. This was the case here.
Table 9 compares the electrical target/actual outputs and the volume flows:
Designation |
Actual electrical power (measured)Actual electrical power (measured) kW |
Electrical power rating plateElectrical power rating plate kW |
Volume flow rate rating plateVolume flow rate rating platem3/h |
Actual volume flow Actual volume flow (according to Eq. <2>)m3/h |
Volume flow rate target Volume flow rate target (according to Eq. <1>)m3/h |
Volume flow rate range 1 (bath 1) |
10,7 |
12,5 |
10 000 |
6272 |
10 000 |
Volume flow bath 2, 3, 4 |
7,1 |
7,5 |
6000 |
5090 |
12 000 |
Bath volume flow 5
|
6,2 |
7,5 |
6000 |
3390 |
6000 |
Volume flow bath 6 and nickel plating |
2,3 |
7,5 |
6000 |
173 |
6000 |
Tab. 9: Comparison of the electrical target/actual output and the volume flow of the exhaust air fans
In Table 9, the actual volume flow was calculated on the basis of the measured electrical fan output. Table 9 also shows the calculated minimum volume flow for each bathroom.
This allows a comparison to be made as to whether the existing exhaust air fans can continue to be used in the future.
A volume flow of 10,000m3/h is taken into account in area 1. An exhaust air volume flow of 3000m3/h is taken into account for bath 1 and approx. 2300m3/h for the other baths such as dechroming, rectangular and long baths.
In area 2, a volume flow of 12,000m3/h is taken into account for baths 2, 3 and 4. For the baths, bath 5 and reserve bath, an exhaust air volume flow of 6000m3/h is taken into account so that joint bath operation is possible in future.
For bath 6 and for the other baths, such as the impact nickel bath and 2 matt nickel-plating baths, an exhaust air volume flow of 6000m3/h is taken into account. An exhaust air volume flow of 4000m3/h is taken into account for bath 6 and approx. 1000m3/h for each of the other baths, as the matt nickel plating baths are not operated in parallel.
According to the electroplating company, the existing main system components such as scrubbers and fans with efficient motors will be reinstalled in the new production hall. The pipes and ducts with fixtures will be replaced.
Furthermore, the electroplating company intends to check whether it is possible to cover or partially cover the baths to reduce the exhaust air volume flow depending on the electroplating process. These are described in [2].
In the course of installing the supply and exhaust air systems, a heat recovery system (circuit compound system) should also be considered.
The findings obtained above will be taken into account when determining future energy requirements.
3.2.2 Process heating and cooling
Fig. 16: Electricity output curve for the baths and reactive power generation [IB Potthoff]Process heating
To maintain the required galvanic conditions such as
- Maintaining a constant bath temperature
- Creation of an almost homogeneous electrolyte
- maintaining the required heating time before the electroplating process begins
the baths are heated with "Joule heat". This is done by means of "blind current generation". At times when no production is taking place, the reactive current is generated by inserting a workpiece that simulates the electroplating process. The reactive current is controlled depending on the bath temperature of approx. 50 °C.
At times when production is taking place, the reactive current is mainly generated by the heating operation and the thermal losses of the baths.
Figure 16 shows the course of the electrical output of the baths and the reactive power supply over the period from 1.2.2017 to 10.2.2017.
As can be seen from the reactive power consumption curve in Figure 16, the reactive power output is between 25 kW and 50 kW. The reactive power output is higher at weekends than during the week.
Figure 17 shows the ordered annual duration curve of the reactive power output.
Figure 17 shows the maximum reactive power output. The area under the graph shows the annual reactive current work.
This means that this electrical energy could be generated in future by thermal energy with a CHP unit and a boiler to heat the galvanic baths.
The previously determined consumption values for reactive power generation are taken into account when evaluating the alternative heating with a combined heat and power unit.
Designation |
Unit |
Value |
Electricity consumption for reactive power generation |
kWh/a |
221 967 |
Power from reactive power generation |
kW |
50 |
Percentage share of reactive power generation in the electricity consumption of the baths |
% |
12,20 |
Table 10: Data on reactive power generation
Fig. 17: Ordered annual duration curve of the electricity demand of reactive power generation [IB Potthoff]The evaluation of the electricity consumption of reactive power generation over the year 2017 is listed in Table 10.
Process cooling
The downstream systems are cooled using 4 recooling units installed on the basin (hot/cold side).
The systems to be cooled are essentially
- the rectifiers and
- the electroplating baths.
The circuit water is filtered and chemically conditioned. The consumers are hydraulically separated from the cooling circuit via tube bundle coolers.
According to the electroplating company, the cooling process will be retained in the future. The existing cooling system will be reinstalled at the future production site.
Supportive cooling using the waste heat from the combined heat and power plant with an absorption chiller will not be pursued for technical and economic reasons.
-will be continued
Literature
[1] Bavarian State Office for Environmental Protection, Augsburg, Efficient energy use in the electroplating industry, 2003
[2] Fachverband Oberflächentechnik e. V., Hilden, Guideline for the design of exhaust air systems, 2003